Home / Insurance SEO

Insurance SEO

Insurance SEO that brings in more quote requests and calls

Insurance is one of the most competitive spaces in search. We help carriers, brokers and agencies win the searches that bring in quote requests and calls in every market they serve.

Quote pageexample page

Home insurance in Ontario

yourbrokerage.com/home-insurance/ontario
Ranking for home insurance in OntarioPage one
Named in AI answers about local brokersChatGPT
Quote form above the foldMobile
Office page for MississaugaNext up
WahiShopifyRBCHGregoireGGPokerHomebaseBrilliant EarthOpencare

What makes insurance search hard to win

Comparison sites, national carriers and the local agent down the street all want the same searches. Google is also stricter with insurance pages, so ones written only to rank don't last.

01

Comparison sites own the biggest searches

A search like "car insurance quotes" is full of aggregators and national brands with big budgets. Going straight at those terms first is slow and expensive.

02

Pages with no named expert struggle

Insurance pages affect people's money, so Google looks for real expertise behind them. A page with no named author or credentials has a hard time ranking.

03

One page trying to cover every state

Coverage rules and prices change from one state or province to the next. A single national page can't cover them all, so a competitor with a local page gets the click.

What our insurance SEO gets you

We only go after searches for the products you sell, in the places you're licensed to sell them.

01

Page one for your product lines

Auto, home and commercial searches are some of the most crowded online. We aim for page one for your lines in each state or province you cover, starting where you can win soonest.

02

Every office and agent in the map pack

For local insurance searches, Google shows a few agencies on a map above the other results. Full profiles, office pages and steady reviews are how your offices earn those spots.

03

Recommended when people ask AI about coverage

AI tools now explain insurance and name providers. We work to get your brand into those answers by earning mentions on the independent sites these tools learn from.

04

A fair, positive picture in AI answers

Being named is only part of it. What ChatGPT and AI Overviews say about your coverage and service matters too, so we keep an eye on it and work on anything they get wrong.

05

A strong reputation on Google

Steady reviews on Google and the review sites in your market help you in local search and in what AI tools say about you. We help you keep them coming in.

06

More quote requests and calls

Rankings only matter when they bring in business. We track the quote requests and calls each page brings in, then put more effort behind the pages and markets that pay.

More quote requests across every line and market

An independent agency usually wins on local search, with office pages and reviews. A carrier or insurtech competes with comparison sites in many markets, often with a quote flow built in JavaScript.

Brokers are often somewhere in between. We build the plan around whichever one you are, and you'll see which pages and markets bring in quotes and calls.

Product pages for each line you write, with the quote form close by
State and province pages only where you're licensed, each with real local detail
Office and agent pages each tied to its own Google Business Profile
Plain-language explainers on coverage, deductibles, claims and local rules
Links and mentions from insurance publications and local news sites
Quote form fixes so it loads fast on phones and the page stays crawlable
A review plan for Google and the review sites in your market
Quote and call tracking so we see which pages bring in business and catch drops

What the first six months look like

We start with the product lines and markets that bring you the most business, then widen from there.

01

Audit and market map

We look at who beats you in each state or province you sell in, comparison sites included. That tells us which searches are worth going after.

02

Build pages

We fix the technical problems first. Then we write quote, office and explainer pages for the lines that bring you the most business.

03

Grow and keep checking

We add pages for more lines and markets and keep reviews coming in. We track quote requests and calls, and tell you about changes as soon as we see them.

Insurance SEO questions we hear a lot

What is insurance SEO?+
Insurance SEO is the work of getting an insurance company, broker or agency to show up when people search for coverage, quotes or a local agent. It covers quote pages for each product line and market, plus local office pages and your Google Business Profile. It also covers plain-language explainers, reviews, technical fixes and showing up in AI tools like ChatGPT. The goal is more quote requests and calls, so that's what we measure.
How is SEO for insurance agents different from SEO for a carrier?+
An agent or a small agency mostly wins on local search. That means a strong Google Business Profile, steady reviews, a page for each office and good pages for the lines you write most. A carrier competes on product searches across many states or provinces, usually against comparison sites and other national brands. So the work is more about site structure and large sets of product and market pages. It also includes technical fixes to quote flows.
Can an insurance agency outrank comparison sites?+
On the biggest national searches, usually not at first, and we'll tell you that up front. Aggregators have huge sites and a lot of links behind them. Searches that name a town, a specific product or a local question are much easier to win. We go after those first and work up to the bigger terms from there.
How long does insurance agency SEO take to bring in quote requests?+
Most agencies should expect about six months before quote requests pick up steadily. Local results like the map pack can move sooner once your Google Business Profile is complete and new reviews are coming in. Competitive product searches across a whole state or country take longer, often a year or more.
Why is Google stricter with insurance websites?+
Google treats pages that can affect someone's money or safety as Your Money or Your Life topics. Insurance falls into that group. Its quality guidelines look for experience, expertise, authority and trust on those pages. That means named authors with real credentials, and facts that are accurate and current. It also means clear contact details and a business that other trusted sites mention. We work on all of it, on your site and off it.
Who writes the content, and who checks it?+
Our in-house writers draft every page, from quote pages to plain-language explainers on coverage, deductibles and claims. An editor then checks each one for clarity and accuracy. None of it is written by AI.
Do you handle insurance compliance?+
No, your team owns compliance. We aren't licensed to sell insurance and we don't give legal or insurance advice. If your compliance or legal team reviews pages before they go live, we put that step in the publishing schedule and make the changes they ask for. A licensed person on your team can also be named as reviewer, which helps with E-E-A-T.
Should we build a page for every state or province?+
Only for the places where you're licensed and where you have something useful to say about the local market. Near-identical pages that only swap out the place name are what Google calls doorway pages. They go against its spam policies and can hurt your rankings. A good state or province page covers what's different there, like required coverage, common local risks and who to call. If you can't fill a page with real local detail, it's better to wait.
How do reviews affect SEO for an insurance agency?+
Reviews are one of the main things that decide who shows up in the map pack when someone nearby searches for an insurance agent. They also feed what AI tools say about local brokers. We set up a steady way to ask happy clients for reviews on Google and the other sites they use. We also help you reply to the ones that come in.
Can you help our brokerage show up in ChatGPT and Google AI Overviews?+
Yes. AI tools form their view of a company from across the web. So we run an awareness campaign that gets you mentioned on independent sites, industry publications and directories these tools read. We also work on how AI describes and compares you. On your own pages, we add structured data and clear answers so they're easy to cite. We keep checking how the main AI tools talk about you. If one starts getting your coverage or markets wrong, we raise it and work on the fix.
What should I look for in an insurance SEO agency?+
Ask who will work on your account, how content gets written and checked, and how they'll tie the work to quote requests instead of traffic alone. Be careful with anyone who promises first-page rankings or wants to publish dozens of AI-written pages a month. On an insurance site, that kind of content rarely ranks for long.
Who will work on our account?+
A senior specialist owns your account, with in-house writers and an editor on the content. We keep our client list small on purpose. The person you meet on the discovery call is the one doing the work, and they stay with you. If quote requests from one of your markets start to slip, they'll raise it before you have to ask. We work inside your tools, like Slack, Teams, Jira or Asana, so your team can reach us easily.

Find out which quote searches you're missing

Book a discovery call. We'll look at who ranks for your product lines in your markets and tell you where we'd start.

Book a discovery call